Comments on Advance Indiana™: When Political Messages Clash With News Headlines

Marco, your "statement" is vapid gibberi...

2011-01-25T10:14:20.202-05:00

Marco, your "statement" is vapid gibberish and raw avoidance of legitimate discussion.

Okay, you hate the police. That much is blatantly...

2011-01-25T02:09:55.395-05:00

Okay, you hate the police. That much is blatantly obvious. Until you can do better I'll just stand behind my previous comment.

Marco, don't try to park a weak argument behin...

2011-01-24T20:45:54.029-05:00

Marco, don't try to park a weak argument behind a fusillade of emotion.

The cops view each other as superior to us. It's a big problem.

Ernie, I'm glad they caught the slimeball. I ...

2011-01-24T14:09:41.801-05:00

Ernie,

I'm glad they caught the slimeball. I have the same questions as AI as to why this guy was on the street. The cops I know say the same thing about the revolving door.

That said, please support your claim that we need twice the police.

Doing admittedly rough math, it looks like Indpls has only slightly more citizens per sworn officer than NYC.

And yes I'm talking about Broken Windows... but it was about busting the turnstyle jumpers and the thugs on the subway that set the tone (oh, and you picked up the guys who had a warrant while you were at it)

Indianapolis operates with half the number of Poli...

2011-01-24T12:26:57.478-05:00

Indianapolis operates with half the number of Police Officers that we need. The LEO’s on every shift are spread out so far in their districts that responding to complaints is about all they can do. With our limited number of officers being proactive in law enforcement is almost extinct.
If given the chance our LEO's would rather catch the bad guys before the deed is done instead of taking the report too late to catch those responsible.
The time to criticize our LEO’s isn’t when one is fighting for his life in a hospital. Those of you who are doing so need to rethink your actions and show a little class.

If you're referring to "Broken Windows,&q...

2011-01-24T12:00:37.226-05:00

If you're referring to "Broken Windows," that's more of a political game where they can claim to be doing something that doesn't cost anything. Everybody seems to forget that when NYC experienced their large drop in crime the size of NYPD increased by nearly 50%. In fact, the drop in crime didn't begin with the implementation of Broken Windows it began earlier when Dinkins ran for reelection on a public safety platform, but that's a conversation for another day.

As a John Q. Citizen, I wouldn't expect 200 cops to show up to the hospital if my family member was injured in such a manner. I also wouldn't expect cops to volunteer their own time and turn their own schedules upside down on a Sunday to help somebody they don't know and have never met. Ditto for a burglary, robbery, etc.

I'm guessing the average cop takes dozens of major felony reports a month. I would think they simply don't have the time or effort to put into every case the same effort they put into a case in which they are instantly emotionally vested. Furthermore, I know there's a theory (dunno if it's commonly held) that people who shoot the police are generally a much, much greater threat to society and everyday citizens than one felon killing another felon for a specific reason (which is much more common these days.) They aren't machines.

Marco, I'm all for kicking ass when a police ...

2011-01-24T09:05:49.311-05:00

Marco,

I'm all for kicking ass when a police officer gets shot. Good that they got the guy.

However, there's a feeling that the same people are doing a lot of the same crimes. I don't know if you've ever had the experience of dealing with a robbery, burglary, etc. and you get the sense that the cop doesn't really care. He's going to file the report and that's about it.

There's a saying that police can't prevent crime - they just show up after it's happened.

But if there were more aggressive efforts at solving "minor" crimes, a lot of these criminals would be off the street and it would be clear that lawlessness isn't tolerated.

It's worked in NYC.

That's a new low Cato. Have some class.

2011-01-24T04:01:47.393-05:00

That's a new low Cato. Have some class.

Why did this particular shooting merit the collect...

2011-01-23T20:10:45.516-05:00

Why did this particular shooting merit the collective attentions of the entire police force? Are the many other shooting victims less deserving of police crime-solving efforts?

It was the first full moon of the year. We're...

2011-01-23T17:16:20.686-05:00

It was the first full moon of the year. We're in for a lot more.

Ballard's the guy who promised to reduce crime...

2011-01-23T16:43:43.535-05:00

Ballard's the guy who promised to reduce crime, eh?

Way to go, Greg!

And, while we're at it, where's your birth certificate? How will we know you're really an American?

And this is why the Ballard message that the crime...

2011-01-23T11:20:07.915-05:00

And this is why the Ballard message that the crime rate is down won't work - the public perception is just the opposite. Even if the Ballard campaign were right about the numbers, the public perception is just the opposite...that things have gotten worse. That makes it a non-starter as a positive political issue.