Comments on Advance Indiana™: Hit And Run, DWI Former Deputy Prosecutor Gets Her Job Back

Declaring my interest, I'm a prosecutor. I am...

2010-06-16T11:52:03.998-05:00

Declaring my interest, I'm a prosecutor.

I am ashamed of and angry about what the Special did.

IFF there was a serious problem with the proof, the Special had an independent duty to dismiss the charges or accept a plea to what hecould do. A prosecutor's job is NOT to try cases he doesn't think he can prove. He's supposed to NOT press those, remember?

Having said that, the reasons for the plea down ought to be open and explained on the record. And on the courthouse steps to the news cameras.

"We can't prove DWI, the machine was defective. Here's the engineering report".

Or, "The law requires a written waiver in order to use the test. The police didn't get one before they gave the test, so it's not admissible."

Otherwise, plea as charged or have a Jury decide.

Because the citizens have a right to VERY TRANSPARENT justice when it's a public official Especially especially if it's law enforcement.

I'm very embarassed by Brizzi. This makes him (and since I do the job too) look corrupt.

As I understand it, she was a hard worker, sharp, and otherwise a credit to the office. Anyone can have a bad day, and that might be a part of a bigger problem that's now been dealt with.

I could BARELY comprehend rehiring her if she took her lumps. But this isn't what happened. How could he be so far from reality to think that this was anything but cruel poison to his former ADA?

Combined with the (apparent) sweetheart deal, people in Indianapolis ought to toss him at the next election.

I still feel sorriest for the victim, and second sorriest for Miss DePrez.

Maybe the drunk driver is doing community service,...

2010-05-21T17:39:15.513-05:00

Maybe the drunk driver is doing community service, was court ordered to work for Carl Brizzi. lol. Seriously, Marion County's prosecutor office must now be the laugh of the nation.

That plea bargain is inappropriate under the circu...

2010-05-21T16:16:51.718-05:00

That plea bargain is inappropriate under the circumstances. Further, DWI has enhanced penalties for repeat offenses, while Reckless Driving does not.

A second DWI within 5 years is a felony. The idea is to address those who fail to correct their problem.

Reckless Driving has specific actions required as elements, it is not a general lesser-included of DWI. Perhaps the Supreme Court's Disciplinary Commission should look into what happened?

Paul, Maybe that is how 1st time DUI's are ha...

2010-05-21T14:32:12.207-05:00

Paul,

Maybe that is how 1st time DUI's are handled in Monroe County where the special prosecutor hails from.

That is not how Marion County or the surrounding counties prosecute DUI's. There better some incredibly insurrmountable problem with the evidence before the deputy prosecutor comes off the DUI.

They say she is punished no more than any first ti...

2010-05-21T12:49:32.620-05:00

They say she is punished no more than any first time offender. Possibly. But what gets me is they allowed her to forego pleading to a DWI. Since when is that an offer made in DWI cases?

No, Cato.

2010-05-21T11:15:28.026-05:00

No, Cato.

dcrutch, Brizzi has lost support from most in his ...

2010-05-21T11:13:11.139-05:00

dcrutch, Brizzi has lost support from most in his own party. The only ones who aren't calling for his resignation, ironically, are the Democrats.

Strangely enough, he seems to have some support among the public. After Brizzi had the WIBC interview 3 weeks ago or so, the DJ who followed the interview just let callers call in and talk about the interview. I don't know if Brizzi sent out a talking point quickly, but at least half of the callers were defending Brizzi. Often using the term "witch hunt", though they couldn't define who was hunting Brizzi.

Brizzi is probably a believer in the free market. Well, I ask Brizzi, and those who support him, this: Would a private employer put up with the non-answers and BS that Brizzi has given the public?

I read a ponderous biography of Huey Long when I w...

2010-05-21T10:34:03.154-05:00

I read a ponderous biography of Huey Long when I was young, and a lesser one about Richard Daley Sr. I have not read extensively about Tammany Hall in New York. I only know about the Kansas City Pendergast machine through a PBS documentary on Truman, who was (at least initially) supported by it.

From my collective recollections on these Democratic machines, I can't think why the actions and inactions of Carl Brizzi shouldn't put him in this company.

Maybe I'm entirely wrong. Would someone like to defend him and explain why he should still be in office as our prosecutor?

Is she the daughter of Ann DePrez, Partner at Barn...

2010-05-21T10:22:33.144-05:00

Is she the daughter of Ann DePrez, Partner at Barnes and Thornburg?