Friday, January 13, 2012

Marion County Judge Upholds Constitutionality Of Indiana's School Voucher Law

Supporters of Indiana's school voucher law won a big case today challenging the constitutionality of the law because it allows state education dollars to flow to religious-supported parochial schools. The Indiana State Teachers Association, which brought the lawsuit, contended the law should be declared unconstitutional because of the state constitution's prohibition on public dollars being used to support a religious institution. Marion Co. Superior Court Judge Michael Keele ruled that the law doesn't violate the constitutional prohibition because the state isn't directly funding the parochial schools with the voucher program; rather, the state gives the vouchers to parents, who get to choose where to use them. There are about 4,000 students enrolled in Indiana's school voucher program. ISTA plans to appeal today's ruling.

3 comments:

Had Enough Indy? said...

Keele is a partisan, activist Judge on the right. Let's wait to see what the ultimate decision of the Courts is. my two cents.

Paul K. Ogden said...

HEI,

Activist? By leaving the issue to the legislature? There is a line of cases that say as long as you give the $$ to the people, they can spend it at religous institutions. We already allow people to use publicly funded scholarships at post-secondary schools, i.e coleges and universities. It is the same thing.

Concerned Taxpayer said...

HEY, HAD ENOUGH...THEN WHAT ABOUT THE LAZY BUMS WHO COLLECT MY TAX DOLLARS EVERY MONTH AND GIVE THEM TO A CHURCH?
ISN'T THAT A "VIOLATION" OF CHURCH & STATE (WORDS THAT DON'T EVEN EXIST IN THE CONSTITUTION.)